Things get awkward when Phil shows up at Claire's college reunion; Jay is fixated on winning a big bowling tournament; a wig malfunction during an elaborate photo shoot with Joe leads to unfortunate results.
Eve refuses to talk about her new boyfriend; Kristin and Mandy are concerned when they think Eve and her boyfriend will both be going on the same junior ROTC overnight camping trip.
Abishola and Kemi hatch a plan to keep Ebun and the new pastor's flirtation from growing; Bob is thrown for a loop when Goodwin leaves MaxDot for a better job at Christina's company.
After Dr. Sturgis experiences a nervous breakdown, Mary worries Sheldon is headed down a similar path; Georgie discovers he has a knack for sales.
Tara Munsey went missing after a work shift at a Virginia restaurant, and it is unknown if she ran away or if she was the victim of foul play.
A community is shocked when police discover a woman raped and murdered in broad daylight on a public trail.
A seller brings in an antique high wheel bike; Chumlee sells one of Rick's prized Japanese katanas to UFC President Dana White; Rick tries to score a restored grand piano from the 1800s and an original Walkman cassette player.
A 1984 Ferrari 308; a phone-operated music player from the 1930s; a cowboy hat that belonged to actor Larry Hagman ("Dallas"); a hockey jersey signed by goalie Marc-André Fleury, who visits the shop to authenticate his signature.