The Butlers and Johnsons are rattled in different ways after an earthquake strikes; Dave goes to extremes trying to prepare his family for the next earthquake.

As Dave nears his 40th birthday, Calvin offers to coach his friend for an amateur boxing tournament; sparks fly when Marty meets a new woman at the gym.

Calvin and Dave are both chosen to serve as jurors on the same trial; Malcolm and Marty get a big surprise when they fail to ask what the movie's about after they rent out their house for a film shoot.

Calvin decides to splurge on an expensive jacket, then worries it's too special to risk wearing outside the house; Dave and Gemma worry their new friends' daughter is a bad influence on Grover.

Tina struggles to keep up with her job at Calvin's auto shop due to her burgeoning baking business; Malcolm delays breaking up with a girlfriend when her son becomes an unexpected asset to his youth baseball team.

Calvin is thrilled when he unexpectedly crosses paths with NFL legend Jerome "The Bus" Bettis -- until he discovers the hall of fame football player shares a history with Tina; Dave deals with the fallout of a romantic revelation.

As Halloween draws near, Calvin tries to determine what's behind the sudden strange occurrences at the Butlers' house; Gemma and Tina question if their days of sexy costumes should be behind them.

When Calvin and Tina enlist the services of a professional matchmaker for Marty, they can't help but get too caught up in the process; Dave and Gemma adopt new roles during an unexpected date night.

When Dave and Gemma face a devastating loss, Calvin and Tina offer emotional support and reflect on a period that tested their own family.

When Gemma hires Alexis to teach at her school, Tina suspects the new teacher may not be quite who she claims to be.

When a member of the community's behavior becomes increasingly erratic, Calvin and Dave step up to help; Marty undergoes a dramatic makeover to impress a longtime crush.

When Dave starts researching his genealogy, he makes a surprising discovery -- he and Calvin are more than just neighbors; Tina offers to help Gemma when she's overcome with morning sickness, and inadvertently stumbles on a new business idea.