As decision day approaches, Kristy spends time with the final two men in her hometown of Chicago and introduces each of them to her family; Kristy must choose between starting a family or continuing along the road to motherhood on her own.

Kristy travels to the hometowns of the final three men to get a closer look at what her future could be like with each of them; upon regrouping in Chicago, she must narrow it down to her final two, causing a heartbreaking elimination.

The remaining five men receive baby simulators to test their skills; Kristy spends more time with each of the men before deciding which hometowns she'll be visiting.

Kristy and Kristin test the men on their physical strength and endurance to see if they can survive a labor simulation; Kristy embarks on hot dates with two of the men.

Kristy and the remaining fathers-to-be participate in a game night that provides a deeper look into their dating and parenting styles; one man's dreams for a romantic date are crushed when he and Kristy are put in charge of a child's birthday party.