
Following the path from victim to verdict, told from the point of view of the people impacted by the case. Exploring how when it comes to murder, it is rare for there to be no prior connection between the killer and the deceased.

Penny Scaggs believes in being a dutiful Christian wife and even teaches local women how to build harmonious relationships; she is later found brutally beaten and stabbed beside her beloved yellow piano.

When Susan Wright's husband, Jeffrey, is found buried in the backyard, stabbed 193 times, people dub her the blue-eyed butcher of the suburbs.

Bad things happen to the people close to Robert Durst; his wife disappears without a trace; his best friend is killed in her home; his neighbor is dismembered and thrown in the Galveston Bay.

When drug-addicted casino owner Ted Binion turns up dead in his mansion, the suspects are pure Vegas: an ex-stripper girlfriend, a contractor who knew where his silver was buried, and a mob boss who launders money through his casino.