Karen Mills was a county court judge and criminal defense attorney in Florida before turning to TV to preside over her own court shows. In her third effort, "Supreme Justice," Mills tackles small-claims court arbitrations in her compassionate way, to which viewers of her previous shows have grown accustomed. As usual with court shows, cases involve friendships gone bad, money disputes and property damage.

A contractor is blamed after a dog escapes through an open gate and is hit by a car; an artist is accused of selling replicas of a client's custom miniature model.

A shopper is blamed after her runaway grocery cart damages a truck; a woman accuses her stepfather of backing out of an agreement to help her buy a car.

A reframed artwork is damaged when it crashes to the floor; a neighbor is accused of causing a rat infestation by throwing rowdy parties in his backyard.

A man is accused of bailing on a promise to help his friend move, but he argues that nothing was packed, and he's still owed for doing what he could.