
Karen Mills was a county court judge and criminal defense attorney in Florida before turning to TV to preside over her own court shows. In her third effort, "Supreme Justice," Mills tackles small-claims court arbitrations in her compassionate way, to which viewers of her previous shows have grown accustomed. As usual with court shows, cases involve friendships gone bad, money disputes and property damage.

A woman accuses her cousin of damaging her car while taking her son to school and seeks reimbursement for the repairs.

A woman blames her brother for the theft of her laptop; a motorist brings an aggressive pedestrian to court for bashing his car with a bottle.

A man sues after he wins a small fortune at the casino, but loses the money to creditors when his ex-girlfriend posts about it on social media.

A woman sues her daughter's stepmother for grabbing the child at her 6th birthday party, then starting a brawl that led to property damage at the party venue.