Karen Mills was a county court judge and criminal defense attorney in Florida before turning to TV to preside over her own court shows. In her third effort, "Supreme Justice," Mills tackles small-claims court arbitrations in her compassionate way, to which viewers of her previous shows have grown accustomed. As usual with court shows, cases involve friendships gone bad, money disputes and property damage.

A woman blames her former friend's germaphobe boyfriend for kicking her out of their home; a man sues an online date for ghosting him at a gala.

A shopper is blamed after her runaway grocery cart damages a truck; a woman accuses her stepfather of backing out of an agreement to help her buy a car.

A woman sues a party host for medical expenses because she was cut getting herself a glass of water.

A man blames his friend after a boating disaster causes his shoulder injury; an unsupervised young teen has a close call with a rogue wave at the beach.