Watch Deadly Daughter Murder Trial with Fubo for $0 Today
The coroner says three gunshot wounds to the head killed Ashley Smylie, and the prosecution team calls on a crime scene investigator who worked at the home where Carly Gregg fatally shot her mother and attempted to shoot her stepfather.
S1, EP32 "The Verdict And Her Fate"
The verdict arrived after just two hours in jury deliberations. Carly Gregg faced life in prison if she was convicted for murder, attempted murder, and tampering with crime scene evidence. Prosecutors told jurors that the defendant was a wayward teenager whose secrets were exposed to parents that she tried so hard to impress. Gregg's defense claimed mental illness took the best of her and resulted in her violent actions.
S1, EP31 "Mental Illness Took Over"
It was the Defense's turn to deliver closing arguments to jurors. This was the final time Carly Gregg's attorneys would address the jury trying to convince them that she was mentally ill when she killed Ashley Smylie, her mom. Her team reiterated their point that Gregg dealt with a mental health crisis at the time of the murder and, therefore, did not know the wrongfulness of her actions.
S1, EP30 "Closing Arguments"
Closing arguments began after the State's psychiatrist wrapped up his testimony. Carly Gregg was just a 14-year-old teen when she killed her mom, Ashley Smylie. Prosecutors charged her as an adult. Instead of taking the State's plea deal, Gregg was confident that they could convince jurors that she was mentally ill when she killed her mom. If convicted she faced life in prison without the possibility of parole.
S1, EP29 "Misdiagnosis"
The jury listened to more of the mental health evaluation conducted on the defendant. Dr. Jason Pickett claimed that not only did the defendant know what she was doing when she killed her mom, Ashley Smylie, she was deceitful and manipulative in what she did and tried to get out of any responsibility for it. In his detailed 85-page mental health report, Dr. Pickett claimed Carly Gregg was misdiagnosed by a child and adolescent psychiatrist who determined that she had bipolar 2 disorder.
